Ep #169 - Inherited Money- What Should You Do First?

Benjamin Haas |

Receiving an inheritance can bring new opportunities and important financial decisions. In this episode of A/B Conversations, Adam Werner and Ben Haas discuss how to manage inherited money, avoid lifestyle creep, understand tax implications, and evaluate the trade-offs of major financial decisions. Learn how to align an inheritance with your values and long-term financial goals so it supports the life you want to live.

Chapters

0:00 Welcome to A/B Conversations
0:27 Why Inheritances Are Tricky
2:00 Windfall Pitfalls and Lifestyle Creep
4:19 Finding the Middle Ground
7:05 Life Stage and Big Tradeoffs
9:23 When Inheritance Changes Retirement
11:17 Taxes and Account Types Matter
13:26 Paperwork Choices and Hidden Dominoes
14:37 Pause and Recenter on Values
17:21 Wrap Up and Disclaimer

Listen on Spotify:

 

 

 

Watch the Full Episode on YouTube:

 

 

Full Transcript:

[00:00:00] Ben Haas: Hi everyone, and welcome to AB Conversations, where we will help you CFP your way out of it. A podcast where you get into the minds of a couple certified financial planners on how we think and feel about everyday financial planning questions, and what should really matter most to you. A healthier financial life starts now. 

 Today we're going to revisit a podcast we did, my gosh, six years ago episode number nine. And I'll tell you, it's a common, common thing for us working with mostly pre-retirees and retirees at some point. Unfortunately, someone in their lives passes away, and maybe they have money coming to them through the form of an inheritance, 

so it's a common conversation for us. We've learned a heck of a lot on how to coach people through those moments, not only because it can certainly be an emotional time, and money and emotions together sometimes become a problem, but because so much of how we guide them really does depend on really what their experience was with money before a windfall, and really kind of understanding not only who they are, but what they prioritize. 

[00:01:15] Adam Werner: Yeah. And from our standpoint, I, you know, I would view this, it's not wildly different the this idea of, "Okay, I've received this inheritance, now what do I do with it?" And guiding people through that thought process or just exploration on, on, "Okay, now what's possible? What does this mean to me?" It's not that different from just our traditional retirement planning, Figure out what's important to them, what is possible at this point, what are, what is truly, what are truly their values. Ideally, we would have kind of all of that laid out so that when new money now comes, it's just out- it just gets easily allocated, right? 

And maybe it accelerates some previous goals. Where we can kind of see some of these pitfalls are when it's not necessarily that aligned. Like, "Here's all the things that are important to me. Now I have these dollars and I can just put it in these envelopes," right? The mental side of that. 

And it can lead to that lifestyle creep. "I now have these extra dollars that I wasn't counting on." This is found money, maybe I wasn't planning on it, and maybe I'm creating new goals or it's 

I'm now spending money on things that I wouldn't have otherwise, but now I feel like I have excess and maybe I'm, y- you said it in, in the prep, it's, you know, "Oh, squirrel," and I gotta go head this other direction when we would, we wouldn't want people to not have this serve them in the way that they would want it to serve them in the long term as well. 

[00:02:48] Ben Haas: Yeah. So let's stick with the negative here for just a minute or two, and then let's move to the positive of coaching people through these moments. The statistics tell us that when people have that kind of windfall, it will be exhausted. 40% of the time it will be exhausted within 12 months, and I think it's for the reasons that you just said, that now I've got the urge, we're very good at wanting things. 

I've got the urge to go do this with it, and we always feel like our job as, as planners is to, you know, sometimes stand between somebody and their money and go, "How can this serve you over the long term, though?" And that's where even our advice with investments on you don't want to eat the goose that's laying the golden eggs. 

We don't want this now gift, in a way,  

to become something that's quickly exhausted when it could have served them in so many ways over time, which I think we have more success stories with the people that we've worked with than those that have maybe put themselves in a difficult spot with exhausting it, and maybe that was their mindset all along, right? 

I'm gonna sound judgmental. You should stretch this out. Maybe it was, "Well, but if I get to do this one thing and that's how I'm gonna remember the person that I love, then 

so be it."  

[00:03:55] Adam Werner: Yeah, and maybe maybe our anecdotal experience here is it's, it's a self-selecting populace, right? The people that work with, the people that work with us are probably working with us because they are thinking ahead, wanting to plan ahead, wanting to, to be efficient with allocation of resources. 

So yeah, maybe our experience isn't, isn't the  

[00:04:15] Ben Haas: 40%, yeah  

[00:04:17] Adam Werner: Y- well, yeah, that's it. That's it. But I think it's important too that it, it doesn't need to be the extremes, right? It doesn't need to be, "Hey, we're not gonna touch this at all, and we're just gonna, we're just gonna save it for the future," as opposed to, "Okay, now I've now received all of these dollars, and I'm just gonna blow through it in 12 months." 

I think our goal, and I know we've said this on many different podcasts, is probably somewhere in the middle, right? How can this actually serve somebody? And let's figure out, is that a short-term thing? Is this just long-term? I'm thinking of a client situation where they've maybe touched some of the principal that they inherited, but we have some mechanisms set up, that is, they're just taking the income that is generated from this, from this lump sum that was now received or there's multiple accounts involved, which maybe we can get into those details. 

Not all inherited dollars are created equal. But sometime it's, it's just, it's just the logistics of, "I wasn't counting on these dollars. Maybe I have some short-term needs that I can just pay off some debt, or I'm gonna take the family on a, on an experience. I'm gonna take, take the kids on vacation," whatever that may be. 

But then it's, "Let's just set this up so I don't have that lifestyle creep. I don't feel, as big of the urge to, like, see maybe a big dollar amount and want to spend big dollar amounts if I can just take the income off of that every year. And maybe that allows me to just have a little bit of a buffer, have a little bit of breathing room from a cash flow perspective." 

And it helps, but it's not taking it off the deep end 

[00:05:51] Ben Haas: Yeah. And it-- I, I may not be thinking of the same client that you are, but nobody has to know that, so I'm not sure why I even brought it up. That was the situation to me too, where the, the children are growing up quickly and you know, to lose both parents in a relatively short period of time kind of felt like they worked so hard for this and they never got to enjoy it. 

While I'm with my kids and they're still young enough to enjoy these experiences with me, we're gonna do it. 

And we knew we were gonna do these projects around the house anyway, so let's get it done. Could that lead to more creep in the future? Sure. But is it still you know, an emotional period of time where that money is gonna serve a specific purpose that is, you know, joy-filled during a difficult time? Totally get it, right? But there's-- the good news is there's been a lot of planning conversations around your point of, well, how can we have the best of both worlds where this can serve a little bit without cutting too much into principal you know, with still maintaining the fact that parent, those two are still young enough that it's not like full retirement is where they're at. 

Unique ways to handle it, and it's our job to kind of figure out the best way to walk them through what's possible and what may be pushing the limits of what's possible. 

[00:07:04] Adam Werner: Yeah. And so- and sometimes it's as simple as phase of life can lead to different conversations around inheritance too, right? If-- I'm just thinking of we work with a lot of the boomer crowd, right? Those that are in their 60s either looking to retire or maybe already retired. And if they've been working with us for a period of time, we probably have a good idea of what is important to them. 

We probably have a plan already laid out, and if they're inheriting from their older parents, then it is maybe more of a streamlined, "Let's just plug these dollars into kind of the plan that we already have built." We've also had some younger clients come to us with inheritance dollars, and we're, we're kind of starting that from scratch, and I think that's where our role as planners just to help people walk through the trade-offs of I could allocate these dollars, and I'll just use the example that we've heard not just one time recently, but, "Hey, I now have these dollars. 

I want to buy another property." It's in the... It-- I want a cabin in the woods, or I want a beach house, you name it. But for a lot of people, yeah, it does. But if, if this was not a, you know, tens of millions of dollars inheritance, th- there probably needs to be some dis-discussion on, okay, but if, if you took a lump sum of these dollars and allocated it over here, then these are the trade-offs, right? 

Maybe that means you're not fully funding your, your kids' educations. Maybe that's not accelerating your potential to retire sooner than  

[00:08:39] Ben Haas: Sure.  

[00:08:40] Adam Werner: Maybe it's just you're losing maybe some flexibility. And again, it's not our job to tell people, you know, which path to take. It's more just to give them the information that we think they need to feel good about whatever decision that is, that they are fully aware of, if I choose this, then I'm also maybe foregoing this other option. 

[00:08:59] Ben Haas: Right  

[00:08:59] Adam Werner: long as they're okay with that, fine. But I think, again, I think that's our role in the process regardless. I just used the example of somebody younger. But it is part of our job to just walk people through those trade-offs, especially if there is a, a bigger you know, purchase or just a bigger allocation of dollars that can just have bigger effects 

[00:09:21] Ben Haas: Yeah. So much going through my head. Let's maybe use the, the reverse then. If it's not that younger generation you know, I can think of-- There may be those out there that are listening to this that will go through some sort of inheritance and aren't retired yet, and 

that's gonna be the question. You 

know, they'll come to a planner. We had somebody come to us three years ago, unfortunately lost, you know, s- two people in his life in a short period of time, and now was inheriting, was probably knocking on the door of retirement anyway, but that was 

the first question. Like, "Does this now afford me the ability to do it?" And then, right, so we gotta do that planning work first, 

but then it became like now we're reversing the conversation with them and saying: "Well, if you already maybe had enough on your own, how is this inheritance gonna serve you in a new and different way, in ways that you maybe never 

expected or flirted with?" 

And I can kind of remember if, if you know who I'm talking about. We're sitting in the conference room, and we're not getting a lot out of this guy emotionally anyway. Like, the, the conversation just wasn't really going anywhere because, again, I don't think they ever gave themselves permission to think that way. 

But even us just bringing that up, it was almost like leaving some air around the logs of the fire and, you know, the next time they came in three months later, like there was already things in motion for them to purchase, purchase that second property. 

But it w- it didn't come out of nowhere because if you look back to what they valued, certainly daughter wasn't living super close to them you know, had this hobby of something he really enjoys that them finding that second property that was closer to his hobby and closer to the daughter kind of just like checked all the boxes. 

And it was, I-- Again, I'll take credit hopefully for a good process that we have and our willingness to talk people through this. I think just giving them permission to kind of explore what this could mean to them really changed how they approached making that happen. And I, I mean, they sound very happy about it, very happy about their decision 

[00:11:15] Adam Werner: Yeah. Yes. Yeah, and maybe taking a slightly different angle here. You know, I think I've just kind of been thinking, and I think it is more just where w- what we're seeing for the vast majority of the, the clients that we work with, they're inheriting non-retirement dollars, right? The, the 80s and 90-year-olds that are passing away and, and leaving money to their 60-year-old children, our clients they didn't necessarily save in retirement accounts. 

So it made that transition or that, that inheritance process maybe a little bit cleaner from a tax standpoint. But I think as we move forward, and certainly for, you know, our clients, it's the unfortunate reality of we, we are going to have, we have had clients pass away with good sized retirement accounts, and that can create other planning issues where we can't necessarily view that as a big lump sum that could just be allocated to these goals because of taxes, 

Right 

So it's sometimes that is just a limitation of even if, even if it was clear for this, you know, I'll... this imaginary client that is, "I know my values. This is important to me. I want to check these boxes," but there could be restrictions on access to the dollars without, I don't want to say without penalty, because taxes, they shouldn't be looked at as a penalty, but maybe I'll just say  

[00:12:40] Ben Haas: It kind of feels that way. 

[00:12:42] Adam Werner: But knowing that, a- again, you said it earlier, right? These, these are dollars that somebody had to earn and accumulate and be a good steward of up until this point to even have assets to pass along. So that's not lost on us, and I know that's not lost on them. But wanting to be efficient from a tax standpoint, there are just the, the type of account or the type of dollars that are being inherited can also throw a wrench into some of these conversations too. 

[00:13:15] Ben Haas: Yeah. I'm not gonna go buy that $250,000 cabin with a $250,000 inherited IRA withdrawal 'cause fully taxable. What's the tax bracket on that one? 

So point well made, and I, I appreciate you sharing that because there are so... And we shouldn't-- I don't wanna get too deeps into the weeds here. When we say managing an in- an inheritance, it's our job to kind of understand some of those logistics, but we've certainly had situations too where somebody passed away and the, I'll say the client, whether we were working them, with them at that time or not, they just start filling out paperwork. 

And, you know, sometimes that paperwork's like, "How do you want this money? Do you want it spread out over time? You want it in one lump sum? You wanna reinvest it?" And someone 

checks lump sum not knowing or being coached through what that may mean from a tax perspective. So 

it's just a... I know for most people, especially during an emotional time, there's just so many logistics that go into settling an estate and paperwork that's necessary, and how you're gonna move money from one person's name to 

the other, that it really is a good time to make sure that you're speaking with somebody like us, if not us to kind of understand, to your point, what are the dominoes of any of those just logistical decisions, let alone what you're gonna do with it after that money's now in your name. 

[00:14:34] Adam Werner: Yeah. Yeah. Very good point 

[00:14:37] Ben Haas: It's definitely a pivot point in life, right? Where whether it was expected or unexpected, we have certain clients who they tell us all the time, "Well, I know I got money coming to me, so maybe I'm a little looser with my spending in retirement because of it." But whether it was expected or unexpected, it's definitely a time to just pause. And I say that not only because we do wanna be conscious of most times there's, you know, some emotional tie  

to this event happening, and that's a good time to kind of just take a step back and breathe a little bit. 

But it's just definitely worth the re- the real opportunity with an inheritance is to accelerate the life that you already decided you wanted 

and not to just, I don't wanna say, like, make an ill-advised move, but make a 

knee-jerk reaction to here's how now this is now gonna serve me. Like, taking a couple deep breaths and having a conversation is a really important place to start 

[00:15:29] Adam Werner: Yeah. And s- I'll take that one step further. It's... We coach clients, widows usually, right, through that same kind of thought process. Don't make any quick financial decisions in a time where emotions can be running very high, knowing that some of these decisions may be irrevocable. 

And yes, worst case scenario is now we've made a, a quick decision, and now we gotta live with the unintended consequences that we may not love after the fact, but what's done is done, and now we just have to, now we just have to deal. 

So yes, I think that is an important, that is an important distinction here, Ben. That is, this is going to happen, right? As, as wealth gets transferred from one generation to the next, it is important to either have your values clearly defined, or if you don't and you're now inheriting dollars, now's the time  

[00:16:24] Ben Haas: Let's start there  

[00:16:25] Adam Werner: yeah, really assess what would I like to see happen, and how can this money truly serve me at its basest purpose of my, my life. 

And that's different for everybody, but you know, we are strong believers that money is just a tool to live the life that we would want to live, and we would want somebody making decisions with kind of that in mind, and not just, "Oh, there's a shiny object, I'm gonna allocate dollars there," and, "Here's something else I wanna do, I'm gonna allocate dollars there." 

So yes, from our standpoint, like every, every, you know, planning topic we talk about, what's important to them should matter. And that, is it the Ro- I think it's Roy Disney, that when your values are clear, the decision-making becomes clearer and easier moving forward. And we would assume that should be the same case here when there is maybe just found money or unexpected windfalls that people weren't planning on 

[00:17:18] Ben Haas: So good. So well said. Thank you 

[00:17:21] Adam Werner: Okay, next time. I'll see you  

[00:17:22] Ben Haas: See ya.  

[00:17:28] Adam Werner: Hey everyone, Adam and I really appreciate you tuning in. Please note that the opinions we voiced in the show are for general information only, and are not intended to provide specific recommendations for any individual. To determine which strategies or investments may be most appropriate for you, consult with your attorney, your accountant, and financial advisor, or tax advisor prior to making any decisions or investing. Thanks for listening.  

 

Investment Advice offered through Great Valley Advisor Group, a Registered Investment Advisor. Great Valley Advisor Group and Haas Financial Investment Advice offered through Great Valley Advisor Group, a Registered Investment Advisor. Great Valley Advisor Group and Haas Financial Group are separate entities. This is not intended to be used as tax or legal advice. Please consult a tax or legal professional for specific information and advice. are separate entities. This is not intended to be used as tax or legal advice. Please consult a tax or legal professional for specific information and advice. 

Ticket #T011855